Is Knowing Clinical Criteria Sufficient to be a CDIS?

The practice of medicine takes clinical criteria into consideration, but clinical judgment can override criteria.

As I was deleting emails one morning, I saw a picture of Cynthia Tang, as in Pinson & Tang, authors of the annually updated CDI Pocket Guide.

I had never met her, so I was surprised. It used to happen to me a lot in the emergency department – you talk to a doctor almost every day and formulate a picture in your head of what the person behind the voice would look like, and then the first time you meet him at a work event, you are shocked to see that he has a bushy red beard and is toweringly tall.

I then noticed the title of her article, which really turned out to be more of a plug for their CDI Pocket Guide, “Positioning Coders for CDI Success.” Let me preface this by stating that some of the best clinical documentation improvement specialists (CDISs) I have known came from the health information management (HIM) world and were not nurses. Ms. Tang said, “coding specialists, not just nurses, can and should perform the CDI function.” She further stated that “just as CDI specialists benefit from learning coding guidelines and principles, coding specialists can and should learn the clinical criteria.”

I agree that the best CDI specialists understand and stay current on coding guidelines and principles. They also have excellent relationships with their coding colleagues and are not reluctant to ask for input or explanations of the coding rules. I also believe that coding specialists can and should learn clinical criteria. Again, it makes them better at their job.

But clinical criteria are only one facet of clinical medicine. If we were really able to distill medicine down to clinical decision tools, we wouldn’t need clinicians. Watson, the supercomputer, really could replace doctors.

However, that is not the case. There are some diagnoses that are made strictly by a positive test or by checking boxes in a set of clinical criteria. An X-ray with a fracture line indicates a broken bone. A urinary tract infection (UTI) that grows out E. coli >100,000 CFU signifies an E. coli UTI. A creatinine reading of 5.0 indicates renal failure (be it acute or chronic). Rheumatoid arthritis requires inflammatory arthritis of three or more joints, positive rheumatoid factor, duration of more than six weeks, elevated CRP or ESR indicating an inflammatory process, and inability to attribute symptoms to a different condition. Even with distinct decision points, there is often room for exception. And even with distinct diagnostic criteria, there is often room for clinical judgment.

The best example I can offer is sepsis. Sepsis is not a disease process that can be diagnosed by a set of abnormal vital signs and laboratory tests. The Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) score is not the definitive means to make the diagnosis. Sepsis is a clinical syndrome recognized by competent clinicians trying to prevent out-of-control infections from resulting in death. It has a multitude of presentations, the commonality being organ dysfunction due to a dysregulated host response to a localized infection. Learning and scouring for clinical criteria may capture some of the cases, but it will miss others that require a keen clinical eye.

Can coders have a clinical eye? Absolutely. Ask Lisa Lorenzi and Kathy Murchland, ex-colleagues who are shining examples of coders-turned-savvy-CDISs. It takes the ability to read charts and recognize patterns, an inquisitiveness to encourage clinicians to share their thought processes, and it takes experience. I do not believe that a newly trained coder without previous medical exposure (e.g., was a paramedic in a previous lifetime) could serve as a CDIS. I believe it takes some years of scrutinizing medical records, reading literature, and trying to glean the story from the documentation. I think the best way to learn is from reviewing cases and having a clinician explain what they often don’t document. Why did you think that? How did you know that the condition was present or ruled out? What were you looking for when you did this test? Why didn’t you think they had that disease?

CDI is really about reading between the lines, finding the diagnoses that are intimated, but not asserted in the record. It is about following the narrative and timeline, and clinically validating whether the documentation and diagnoses make sense. When I do a chart review, my brain is trying to piece together the clinical indicators to make hypotheses, to see if I can deduce what is going on, and then see if the documentation confirms it, refutes it, or just misses the boat. This is not easily taught, nor can it be written down in a 250-page “CDI Bible.”

Coders who want to be CDISs can do several things to achieve their goal:

  • Use clinical criteria as guidelines, not indisputable rules. Recognize that there are exceptions, and try to understand why, in this case, the providers didn’t think the indicators were consistent with that clinical condition, even though the clinical criteria would have suggested it was present.
  • Talk to providers and nurse CDISs to have them explain their thought processes. Have them present clinical topics at your staff meetings. Attend society conferences where clinicians are presenting. Read articles that have case studies or case reports. Establish a relationship with a provider or physician advisor, and bounce questions off them. See if you can join elbow rounds on occasion.
  • Examine the chart like a reader, not like an editor or proofreader. Try to understand the story; don’t just be scanning for missing CCs or MCCs. Don’t just accept or reject computer-assisted codes.

The practice of medicine takes clinical criteria into consideration, but clinical judgment can override criteria. There are many useful reference books and websites, but they are not going to make anyone a clinician; it takes understanding of the pathophysiology and keeping the patient front and center at all times. Clinical documentation integrity specialists, be they nurses or coders, would do well to remember this.

Programming Note: Dr. Remer co-hosts Talk Ten Tuesdays with Chuck Buck every Tuesday at 10 a.m. EST.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Erica Remer, MD, FACEP, CCDS, ACPA-C

Erica Remer, MD, FACEP, CCDS, ACPA-C has a unique perspective as a practicing emergency physician for 25 years, with extensive coding, CDI, and ICD-10 expertise. As physician advisor for University Hospitals Health System in Cleveland, Ohio for four years, she trained 2,700 providers in ICD-10, closed hundreds of queries, fought numerous DRG clinical determination and medical necessity denials, and educated CDI specialists and healthcare providers with engaging, case-based presentations. She transitioned to independent consulting in July 2016. Dr. Remer is a member of the ICD10monitor editorial board and is the co-host on the popular Talk Ten Tuesdays weekly, live Internet radio broadcasts.

Related Stories

Defining High-Quality Documentation

Defining High-Quality Documentation

Last week I wrote about the importance of defining what clinical documentation is, within the scope of clinical documentation integrity (CDI) reviews. This week, I’ll

Read More

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

The Cost of Ignoring Risk Adjustment: How HCCs Impact Revenue & Compliance

The Cost of Ignoring Risk Adjustment: How HCCs Impact Revenue & Compliance

Stop revenue leakage and boost hospital performance by mastering risk adjustment and HCCs. This essential webcast with expert Cheryl Ericson, RN, MS, CCDS, CDIP, will reveal how inaccurate patient acuity documentation leads to lost reimbursements through penalties from poor quality scores. Learn the critical differences between HCCs and traditional CCs/MCCs, adapt your CDI workflows, and ensure accurate payments in Medicare Advantage and value-based care models. Perfect for HIM leaders, coders, and CDI professionals.  Don’t miss this chance to protect your hospital’s revenue and reputation!

May 29, 2025
I050825

Mastering ICD-10-CM Coding for Diabetes and it’s Complications: Avoiding Denials & Ensuring Compliance

Struggling with ICD-10-CM coding for diabetes and complications? This expert-led webcast clarifies complex combination codes, documentation gaps, and sequencing rules to reduce denials and ensure compliance. Dr. Angela Comfort will provide actionable strategies to accurately link diabetes to complications, improve provider documentation, and optimize reimbursement—helping coders, CDI specialists, and HIM leaders minimize audit risks and strengthen revenue integrity. Don’t miss this chance to master diabetes coding with real-world case studies, key takeaways, and live Q&A!

May 8, 2025
2025 Coding Clinic Webcast Series

2025 ICD-10-CM/PCS Coding Clinic Update Webcast Series

Uncover critical guidance. HIM coding expert, Kay Piper, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, provides an interactive review on important information in each of the AHA’s 2025 ICD-10-CM/PCS Quarterly Coding Clinics in easy-to-access on-demand webcasts, available shortly after each official publication.

April 14, 2025

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

The Two-Midnight Rule: New Challenges, Proven Strategies

The Two-Midnight Rule: New Challenges, Proven Strategies

RACmonitor is proud to welcome back Dr. Ronald Hirsch, one of his most requested webcasts. In this highly anticipated session, Dr. Hirsch will break down the complex Two Midnight Rule Medicare regulations, translating them into clear, actionable guidance. He’ll walk you through the basics of the rule, offer expert interpretation, and apply the rule to real-world clinical scenarios—so you leave with greater clarity, confidence, and the tools to ensure compliance.

June 19, 2025
Open Door Forum Webcast Series

Open Door Forum Webcast Series

Bring your questions and join the conversation during this open forum series, live every Wednesday at 10 a.m. EST from June 11–July 30. Hosted by Chuck Buck, these fast-paced 30-minute sessions connect you directly with top healthcare experts tackling today’s most urgent compliance and policy issues.

June 11, 2025
Open Door Forum: The Changing Face of Addiction: Coding, Compliance & Care

Open Door Forum: The Changing Face of Addiction: Coding, Compliance & Care

Substance abuse is everywhere. It’s a complicated diagnosis with wide-ranging implications well beyond acute care. The face of addiction continues to change so it’s important to remember not just the addict but the spectrum of extended victims and the other social determinants and legal ramifications. Join John K. Hall, MD, JD, MBA, FCLM, FRCPC, for a critical Q&A on navigating substance abuse in 2025.  Register today and be a part of the conversation!

July 16, 2025

Trending News

Prepare for the 2025 CMS IPPS Final Rule with ICD10monitor’s IPPSPalooza! Click HERE to learn more

Get 15% OFF on all educational webcasts at ICD10monitor with code JULYFOURTH24 until July 4, 2024—start learning today!

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24