News Alert: Ruling paves way for trial in landmark class-action suit over patient status

Plaintiffs allege they were forced to pay thousands for SNF care following outpatient/observation status assignment.

A federal judge has denied the government’s bid to put a stop to a landmark class-action lawsuit centering on patient status, paving the way for a trial expected to begin later this year.

In Alexander v. Azar, the plaintiffs allege they were forced to pay up to $30,000 apiece for skilled nursing facility (SNF) care after being designated outpatients in observation status, rather than inpatients, according to a press release on the matter by The Center for Medicare Advocacy (CMA).

In his 50-page opinion, U.S. District Court Judge Michael P. Shea, sitting in Connecticut, reportedly denied the government’s motion for summary judgment, motion to “decertify” the suit, and motion to dismiss the case, concluding that the evidence the plaintiffs submitted could reasonably establish that physician decisions about whether to classify patients as inpatients are “meaningfully constrained” by criteria set by Medicare.

The plaintiffs, therefore, may possess a “property interest” in the Medicare coverage they seek, CMA noted: a necessary component of their constitutional due-process claim.

“Although care provided to patients on observation status is often indistinguishable from inpatient care, it does not count toward the three-day inpatient hospital stay requirement for Medicare coverage of nursing home care,” CMA explained in its press release. “This leaves beneficiaries with the burden of paying for – or forgoing – extremely costly nursing and rehabilitative care. The opportunity to appeal is critical because of the severe ramifications that can result from the observation status categorization.”

CMA singled out plaintiff Ervin Kanefsky of Pennsylvania, a 93-year-old World War II veteran who had to pay approximately $10,000 for nursing home care after being hospitalized for a shoulder fracture for five days, as being emblematic of the issue. He was reportedly initially admitted as an inpatient, but later told that the “powers that be” had changed his status to observation before he was discharged.

The plaintiffs’ lead attorney, CMA’s Alice Bers, welcomed the judge’s ruling in a court proceeding initiated eight years ago. 

“People who have paid into Medicare their whole lives, and who risk having to pay thousands of dollars for necessary medical care, deserve a fair process to determine whether they will receive Medicare coverage,” she said.

 â€śWe look forward to showing at trial that these vulnerable patients have a right to appeal to Medicare as matter of constitutional due process,” added co-counsel Luke Liss of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati.

The use and apparent abuse of observation and outpatient status has been a lightning rod for criticism in healthcare circles for years, and it is widely thought that a clear ruling in a high-profile suit such as this will help establish firmer guidelines on the legitimate application.

“Observation status creates all kinds of harm,” said CMA founder and Executive Director Judith A. Stein, JD in a statement to RACmonitor. “Due process for beneficiaries is crucial to trying to mitigate that harm – and due process requires notice AND a hearing so the people who are harmed can challenge it.” 

Dr. Ronald Hirsch, MD, FACP, CHCQM, vice president of the Regulations and Education Group at R1 Physician Advisory Services and a member of the Advisory Board of the American College of Physician Advisors and the American Case Management Association, told RACmonitor.com that lingering questions remain about what the ramifications might be, should a suit such as this prove successful. 

“This decision is a fascinating read. The judge clearly understands the issues and in fact understands the two-midnight rule better than many hospitals and auditors,” Hirsch said. “I do have a concern that if Medicare patients who are outpatients with observation get immediate appeal rights, the costs to continue care awaiting the appeal decision will fall squarely on the hospital if the QIO (Quality Improvement Organization) agrees observation is appropriate. The three days awaiting the appeal decision will also expose patients to the ongoing risks of hospital care.”

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Mark Spivey

Mark Spivey is a national correspondent for RACmonitor.com, ICD10monitor.com, and Auditor Monitor who has been writing and editing material about the federal oversight of American healthcare for more than a decade.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

I050825

Mastering ICD-10-CM Coding for Diabetes and it’s Complications: Avoiding Denials & Ensuring Compliance

Struggling with ICD-10-CM coding for diabetes and complications? This expert-led webcast clarifies complex combination codes, documentation gaps, and sequencing rules to reduce denials and ensure compliance. Dr. Angela Comfort will provide actionable strategies to accurately link diabetes to complications, improve provider documentation, and optimize reimbursement—helping coders, CDI specialists, and HIM leaders minimize audit risks and strengthen revenue integrity. Don’t miss this chance to master diabetes coding with real-world case studies, key takeaways, and live Q&A!

May 8, 2025

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Navigating the 3-Day & 1-Day Payment Window: Compliance, Billing, and Revenue Protection

Navigating the 3-Day & 1-Day Payment Window: Compliance, Billing, and Revenue Protection

Struggling with CMS’s 3-Day Payment Window? Join compliance expert Michael G. Calahan, PA, MBA, CCO, to master billing restrictions for pre-admission and inter-facility services. Learn how to avoid audit risks, optimize revenue cycle workflows, and ensure compliance across departments. Critical for C-suite leaders, providers, coders, revenue cycle teams, and compliance teams—this webcast delivers actionable strategies to protect reimbursements and meet federal regulations.

May 15, 2025
Audit-Proof Your Wound Care Procedures: Expert Insights on Compliance and Risk Mitigation

Audit-Proof Your Wound Care Procedures: Expert Insights on Compliance and Risk Mitigation

Providers face increasing Medicare audits when using skin substitute grafts, leaving many unprepared for claim denials and financial liabilities. Join veteran healthcare attorney Andrew B. Wachler, Esq., in this essential webcast and master the Medicare audit process, learn best practices for compliant billing and documentation, and mitigate fraud and abuse risks. With actionable insights and a live Q&A session, you’ll gain the tools to defend your practice and ensure compliance in this rapidly evolving landscape.

April 17, 2025
Utilization Review Essentials: What Every Professional Needs to Know About Medicare

Utilization Review Essentials: What Every Professional Needs to Know About Medicare

Dr. Ronald Hirsch dives into the basics of Medicare for clinicians to be successful as utilization review professionals. He’ll break down what Medicare does and doesn’t pay for, what services it provides and how hospitals get paid for providing those services – including both inpatient and outpatient. Learn how claims are prepared and how much patients must pay for their care. By attending our webcast, you will gain a new understanding of these issues and be better equipped to talk to patients, to their medical staff, and to their administrative team.

March 20, 2025

Rethinking Observation Metrics: Standardizing Data for Better Outcomes

Hospitals face growing challenges in measuring observation metrics due to inconsistencies in classification, payer policies, and benchmarking practices. Join Tiffany Ferguson, LMSW, CMAC, ACM, and Anuja Mohla, DO, FACP, MBA, ACPA-C, CHCQM-PHYADV as they provide critical insights into refining observation metrics. This webcast will address key issues affecting observation data integrity and offer strategies for improving consistency in reporting. You will learn how to define meaningful metrics, clarify commonly misinterpreted terms, and apply best practices for benchmarking, and gain actionable strategies to enhance observation data reliability, mitigate financial risk, and drive better decision-making.

February 25, 2025

Trending News

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24Â